Agentic Index
Ashby vs Gem (2026)
Ashby last verified ·Gem last verified
Ashby and Gem both collapse the recruiting stack into one platform, from opposite directions. That verdict is the Agentic Index coverage score, graded from each vendor's own published materials.
Ashby grew from ATS and analytics outward, from $400 a month, while Gem grew from sourcing and CRM with outbound sequences into a full ATS, sold on custom annual contracts. Choose Ashby when analytics and structured pipeline management lead. Choose Gem when outbound sourcing and candidate nurture lead.
This comparison is published by Agentic Index, an independent agentic AI vendor research platform. Ashby and Gem are each graded against the same 14 capability Agentic Index taxonomy, from the vendor's own public materials under the Agentic Index verification standard, alongside 1,140 researched vendors. No vendor pays for placement and no vendor has reviewed this page. How this evidence is graded
Choose Ashby if
- Analytics depth and reporting across the funnel is your differentiator.
- You want scheduling and interview operations native to the ATS.
- A public entry price of $400 a month suits your process.
Choose Gem if
- Outbound sourcing with sequences is your recruiting motion's engine.
- CRM and nurture over long candidate relationships matter in your market.
- You want sourcing analytics feeding directly into pipeline decisions.
| Feature | A Ashby |
G Gem |
|---|---|---|
| Action & orchestration | ||
|
Integrations & Tool Calling Ability to connect agents to real systems through native integrations, OAuth-authenticated actions, custom tools, APIs, webhooks, or MCP-compatible tools. |
||
|
AshbyIntegrations & Tool Calling Ashby offers a marketplace of more than 250 integrations spanning sourcing, assessment, video interview, job board and post hire tools. Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 connect for sending email and scheduling, with read and write access to calendars, and Ashby does not write or delete messages in users' inboxes. Workday and Juro integrations start and track workflows in those systems on the upper plans, Enterprise can share Ashby data to Snowflake and S3, and the Assistant's tools for emailing candidates and posting to Slack act through these connected systems. Sourceashbyhq.com/pricingread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemIntegrations & Tool Calling Gem integrates natively with applicant tracking systems (Greenhouse, Workday, Lever, iCIMS and more), and all three agents layer on top of the existing system without migration. Greenhouse and Workday each have a dedicated solution page. Email and calendar run through Gmail, over the official Google APIs and SSL with authentication via Google SSO, and through Outlook via the Nylas API. LinkedIn InMail and SMS serve as sequence channels, alongside LinkedIn sourcing. A separate connector directory sits at integrations.gem.com. Gem drafts and sends personalized outreach through the recruiter's own connected mailbox and runs multi step sequences with automated follow ups across email, InMail and SMS. It writes scores, rankings and fraud flags back into the customer's existing ATS, so every application is reviewed, every risk flagged and every interview summarized inside the ATS the team already works in. These are authenticated writes into systems Gem does not own. Sourcegem.com/product/ats, /ai-recruiting-agents and /compliance/securityread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Workflow Orchestration Ability to sequence, branch, retry, route, and combine deterministic workflow nodes with autonomous agent steps. |
||
|
AshbyWorkflow Orchestration The Ashby Assistant chains its tools inside one conversation, finding records, opening their details, then changing an application's stage, adding a note, emailing a candidate or filling a form, and it reports when every action is complete. Custom agents carry instructions, inputs, sources and allowed actions, and a scheduled agent repeats its read only work on a set cadence. Only one agent can be added to a request at a time, so each request is one agent working through several steps, with no workflow engine and no way to combine agents. Sourcedocs.ashbyhq.com/ashby-agentsread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemWorkflow Orchestration Sourcing, application review and fraud detection each get a named agent at a distinct point of one funnel, and the three share one dataset and one interface. The agents do not hand work to each other, and there is no coordinating layer, branching flow or multi step process the customer configures. Each agent works its own part of the workflow from a single platform. Gem's pitch is that a team calibrates one system instead of coordinating several. Outbound sequences are multi step and configurable, with delays, A/B testing and automated follow ups across email, InMail and SMS. A sequence runs as many stages as a recruiter wants, each sent a set number of days after the last. Emails and texts go out automatically, and InMail comes up as a manual step the recruiter is prompted to send. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agentsread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Triggers & Channel Coverage How agents wake up and where they work: schedules, webhooks, message events, CRM events, inbox events, chat, email, voice, and collaboration tools. |
||
|
AshbyTriggers & Channel Coverage Any custom agent can run on a recurring schedule and deliver its results to Slack channels, Slack users or email addresses without anyone starting it. Scheduled runs are read only, and the feature is in open public beta on all plans. People also call the Assistant and custom agents by @mention in Ashby's chat or from Slack, and fixed features such as AI application review and reply tracking respond to new applications and candidate replies. Agents cannot yet be started by an event. Sourceashbyhq.com/product-updates/scheduled-agentsread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemTriggers & Channel Coverage Each inbound application starts work on its own. The AI Application Review Agent scores and ranks every applicant as applications come in, before a recruiter opens the file. The AI Fraud Detection Agent automatically scans every inbound application across six signals and flags suspicious candidates before they reach the team. The AI Sourcing Agent runs continuously, searching 800M+ profiles and surfacing the best past candidates 24/7. Candidate rediscovery scans the existing pipeline before a role is posted. Outbound sequences span email with verified personal addresses, LinkedIn InMail and SMS, with AI drafted personalization, A/B testing and automated follow ups. There is no event framework, webhook or subscription the customer configures. The triggers are the ones Gem wires into the recruiting funnel. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agents and gem.com/product/ai-app-reviewread 2026-09-08 |
||
| Knowledge & context | ||
|
Knowledge Grounding & RAG Ability to ground agent behavior in company data through document ingestion, retrieval, external knowledge APIs, semantic search, or RAG layers. |
||
|
AshbyKnowledge Grounding & RAG The Assistant and custom agents search, filter and open the customer's own recruiting records, including candidates, applications, jobs, interview plans, feedback forms, interview transcripts, openings, notes, emails and texts, and every answer cites the underlying Ashby record. AI Talent Rediscovery matches those stored records against job criteria. The records persist in the customer's Ashby instance and reach far beyond what fits in a single conversation. SourceAshby Knowledge Base Ashby Agents (docs.ashbyhq.com/ashby-agents) and Ashby AI page (ashbyhq.com/ai)read 2026-09-08 |
||
|
GemKnowledge Grounding & RAG Two maintained stores stand behind the agents. The first is a searchable corpus of more than 800 million profiles with verified contact data, queried in natural language and refreshed continuously. The second is the customer's own complete recruiting history held in Gem, covering past applications, previous outreach and its engagement, interview feedback and scorecards, recruiter notes and recent rejections. Gem contrasts this with tools that see only an isolated résumé. The history persists between runs, spans an entire candidate database far past any context window, and stays queryable. Through GeMCP a recruiter can ask plain language questions about candidates, pipelines and analytics and get answers back. Candidate rediscovery depends on this history. Gem scans the existing pipeline before a role is posted and surfaces people who now fit. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agents and /product/crmread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Memory & State Persistence Ability to persist context across a run, conversation, workflow, user, team, or longer-term memory layer. |
||
|
AshbyMemory & State Persistence Previous Assistant conversations are kept under Recents and are searchable, and follow up questions within a conversation carry context. No memory that agents read across conversations is described. Custom agent instructions are settings the customer writes, and the candidate database is Ashby's own record of the hiring pipeline. SourceAshby Knowledge Base Ashby Agents (docs.ashbyhq.com/ashby-agents) and Ashby Assistant release 2026-05-07read 2026-09-08 |
||
|
GemMemory & State Persistence Criteria taught once persist and carry across agents. A team calibrates one agent for inbound applications, sourcing and rediscovery instead of training three systems, so the customer's own preference set is kept and reapplied across runs and across agents. The candidate relationship history (past applications, previous outreach, interview feedback, recent rejections) is the CRM's own business record. Gem also says the more a team uses it, the smarter its recommendations get. Customers cannot set a lifetime for what is retained or control its retention and deletion, and there is no per agent or per workflow memory boundary. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agentsread 2026-09-08 |
||
| Control & trust | ||
|
Human Oversight & Guardrails Approval steps, consent checkpoints, escalation rules, structured guardrails, policy constraints, and pause/resume controls. |
||
|
AshbyHuman Oversight & Guardrails Every Ashby Assistant and custom agent action is held for the user's confirmation before it runs, with approve, reject and refine options in the chat, and email and note drafts are reviewed before they are sent or saved. Custom agents declare which actions they may take, scheduled agents run read only and take write actions only in a follow up the author starts, and admins opt in to each AI feature and can disable agents. Approval chains of several steps also route offers, jobs and openings, approvable from Slack, email and mobile. Sourceashbyhq.com/product-updates/ashby-assistantread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemHuman Oversight & Guardrails Hiring decisions stay with recruiters, while Gem's AI surfaces, ranks and flags. Every match score carries plain language reasoning the team can read, question and override, and scores and criteria are editable at any time. Guardrails sit on the input side. Personally identifiable information is stripped before AI processing, and EEO sensitive inputs and subjective criteria are flagged in real time. No review and approve step sits over an agent action, and there is no approval queue, confidence threshold, hold or gate before an agent acts. The agents mostly rank, flag and draft instead of acting on their own. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agentsread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Security, Identity & Governance RBAC, SSO, auditability, encryption, least-privilege tool access, compliance posture, and data handling policy. |
||
|
AshbySecurity, Identity & Governance SOC 2 Type II is audited annually, with 2024, 2025 and 2026 reports and a SOC 1 Type II on the trust center, available through a standard access request. Single sign on works through SAML or OIDC with the customer's identity provider, included on Plus and Enterprise and $100 a month on Foundations, and SCIM directory sync and custom permission roles come on Plus, which allows three roles, and Enterprise, which has no limit. Enterprise adds an organization wide audit log of about 150 event types. Agent actions run as the user under the permissions already set on each record, and a shared scheduled agent always runs with its author's permissions. Sourceashbyhq.com/resources/securityread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemSecurity, Identity & Governance SOC 2 Type II certification came from an examination by BARR Advisory, facilitated by Vanta, with no exceptions noted in the controls, and followed an earlier SOC 1 certification. Gem is SOC 2 Type 2 compliant alongside GDPR and CCPA. Its infrastructure, including AI features, undergoes annual audits, and SOC 2 reports are available under NDA. A trust center sits at trust.gem.com. Gem hosts on AWS, runs background screening and third party audits, and supports environments under HIPAA or OFCCP oversight, with a dedicated OFCCP page. Gem offers advanced permissions and role based access controls. GeMCP inherits them, so an assistant gets no access beyond what the user is already authorized to see in Gem. Account access is bound through OAuth, with Google SSO for Gmail clients. Sourcegem.com/product/security, /compliance/security and the SOC 2 announcementread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Observability & Auditability Traces, logs, execution histories, metrics, audit events, and debugging detail for production agent behavior. |
||
|
AshbyObservability & Auditability After an Assistant action runs, each action expands to show its details in the conversation, every response cites the source records, and conversations are kept and searchable under Recents, so a user can see what the agent did and on what basis. Since October 2026 Enterprise customers get an organization wide audit log of about 150 event types, filtered by date, category and actor and retrievable through the API, with each entry naming the person or API key responsible. Ashby does not say that agent runs or prompts are among the logged events, so the record of agent work still lives in each user's chat. Sourcedocs.ashbyhq.com/ashby-agentsread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemObservability & Auditability Every match score carries plain language reasoning, and Gem says there are no black box algorithms. Scores are objective and numeric, each explains how a candidate matched, recruiters can read and override the reasoning, and criteria are editable. There is no agent run trace or action log. Nothing records which agent touched which candidate and when, whether a recruiter overrode a score, or what the fraud agent evaluated on a given application. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agents and /product/ai-app-reviewread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Deployment & Data Residency Deployment modes and options, including SaaS, dedicated cloud, VPC, on-prem, hybrid, local runtime, and self-hosting. |
||
|
AshbyDeployment & Data Residency Ashby is hosted on Amazon Web Services, and its privacy policy says personal data is transferred to and processed in the United States. No region list, customer environment option or way to choose a location is published. Ashby holds Data Privacy Framework certification for those transfers, and the trust center's answer on where Ashby is hosted is available only through an access request. SourceAshby Security Overview 2024-12-20, Privacy Policy 2025-09-24, Trust Center (trust.ashbyhq.com); ashbyhq.com/resources/privacyread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
GemDeployment & Data Residency The services run on industry leading cloud providers, with Heroku for application servers and AWS for databases along with other AWS services. AWS hosting brings the provider's data center physical controls. There is no named region list, no VPC, no on premises option and no customer tenant. Customers cannot choose a region for data residency. Sourcegem.com/compliance/security and /product/securityread 2026-09-08 |
||
| Solution readiness | ||
|
Prebuilt Agents, Templates & Packs Ready-made workflows, packaged employees, templates, blueprints, industry solutions, and role-specific agents that reduce time-to-value. |
||
|
AshbyPrebuilt Agents, Templates & Packs Custom agents are written by the customer, generated from a plain language description or built by hand. A start from template option was announced with the release, though the agent creation wizard in the help center does not show it. The use case library holds prompts, and the named AI features, Application Review, Talent Rediscovery, Candidate Assistant and Notetaker, are switched on one at a time inside the product, two of them as paid add-ons. Ashby names no whole prebuilt agents. Sourceashbyhq.com/product-updates/ashby-assistantread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemPrebuilt Agents, Templates & Packs Three named agents ship out of the box, each with its own product page. The AI Sourcing Agent searches 800M+ profiles and surfaces the best past candidates around the clock. The AI Application Review Agent scores and ranks every applicant before a recruiter opens the file, with plain language reasoning for each score. The AI Fraud Detection Agent scans every inbound application across six signals and flags suspicious candidates before they reach the team. Each does a whole job at a different point of the funnel for a different problem. Customers adopt all three with no build step, either on top of their existing ATS or inside Gem's own platform. Ideal Profiles and AI Talent Insights are further named assets customers can adopt. Each agent is sold separately. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agents and the three agent product pagesread 2026-09-08 |
||
| Platform extensibility | ||
|
Model Flexibility & Routing Ability to work across multiple foundation models, route tasks to different models, or let buyers bring their own providers and keys. |
||
|
AshbyModel Flexibility & Routing Ashby says it uses third party AI models and names OpenAI, under a DPA, and customers and admins get no choice of model. The full subprocessor list and the trust center's answer on where the AI model is hosted are available only on request, so whether a second LLM provider is used is not published. Assembly AI and Recall AI handle transcription for the Notetaker add-on. SourceAshby AI page FAQ (ashbyhq.com/ai) and Trust Center subprocessor updatesread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
GemModel Flexibility & Routing There is no model picker, admin setting or bring your own model option, and Gem does not describe how it routes between models. It names no model provider for its own agents. GeMCP connects Claude and ChatGPT to Gem data, which lets the customer choose the assistant that reads Gem, not the model that runs Gem's agents. BABL performs annual third party bias auditing of Gem's AI. Tofu, a specialist fraud detection company, powers the Fraud Detection Agent, and customers cannot swap it for another option. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agents and /blog/introducing-gems-fraud-detection-agentread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
APIs, SDKs & MCP Extensibility Composability layer: stable APIs, SDKs, MCP tool consumption/serving, custom tools, and integration into internal systems. |
||
|
AshbyAPIs, SDKs & MCP Extensibility Ashby's own platform can be called from outside through a public developer API at developers.ashbyhq.com, with versioned releases and endpoints added through 2026, and API access is listed on every plan. Customers generate and regenerate their own access keys, Enterprise adds an Offer Approval API and an audit log endpoint, and the Ashby MCP server, in beta on all plans, connects Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, Glean and Gemini CLI to Ashby data. Sourceashbyhq.com/pricingread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemAPIs, SDKs & MCP Extensibility GeMCP is Gem's own MCP server, with a getting started guide in the help center. It gives approved AI tools like Claude and ChatGPT secure, permissioned access to Gem data. Users ask plain language questions about candidates, pipelines and analytics and get answers back, with no exports, no copy and paste and no access beyond what they are already authorized to see in Gem. An outside assistant drives Gem through it. A separate legal and security FAQ covers the permission model and the rule that the organization must authorize the connecting tool. There is no developer portal, API reference, endpoint list or SDK. The site at integrations.gem.com is a connector directory, not a place to build. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agents and help.gem.com GeMCP guidesread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
Testing, Debugging & Optimization Testing, debugging, scoring, retries, fallbacks, quality gates, and optimization loops for improving agent workflows before and after deployment. |
||
|
AshbyTesting, Debugging & Optimization Customers get no harness, test cases, quality gate or optimization loop for the Assistant or custom agents. Agent management in the help center covers creating, editing and disabling agents and a step that generates a draft, and the sandbox instance on the pricing table is a separate environment for testing configuration outside production. Ashby runs FairNow bias audits and lists Braintrust, an AI observability and evaluation service, as a subprocessor, both part of its own model evaluation and engineering work. Sourcedocs.ashbyhq.com/ashby-agentsread 2026-11-03 |
||
|
GemTesting, Debugging & Optimization Recruiters tune the agents. They teach the AI what good looks like once, calibrate a single agent across inbound applications, sourcing and rediscovery, and can edit the criteria fed to each agent at any time. Every score is explainable and editable, so each correction is visible. There is no test environment, simulation, versioning, scored test case or holdout. A criteria change cannot be tried before it runs on live applicants, and the review agent scores every applicant before a human sees the file. Gem's AI undergoes annual third party bias auditing through BABL, with year round internal governance. The audit covers Gem's AI in general and is not run against the customer's own agent inside the product. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agentsread 2026-09-08 |
||
| Specialist automation | ||
|
Browser & Computer Use Browser, desktop, or remote/local computer control for workflows that cannot be handled through stable APIs alone. |
||
|
AshbyBrowser & Computer Use The agents act through Ashby's own tools, and no browser, desktop or computer control is described. The sourcing Chrome extension is for recruiters, who use it to add candidates from a web page into Ashby. SourceAshby AI page (ashbyhq.com/ai), pricing feature table, Knowledge Base Ashby Agentsread 2026-09-08 |
||
|
GemBrowser & Computer Use The agents do not use a hosted or local browser or a desktop session, and they do not control a computer remotely or locally. They search a profile corpus, score applications and write into the customer's ATS through native integrations and APIs. Gem began as a Chrome extension for sourcing on LinkedIn, and recruiters can add candidates in one click from LinkedIn and many other sites. That capture works from a page the recruiter has already opened, and the agent does not operate the browser. No automation drives the customer's authenticated LinkedIn account on its own, such as profile visits, connection requests and messaging. Sourcegem.com/ai-recruiting-agentsread 2026-09-08 |
||
Pricing snapshot
Sourced from the Index pricing dataset · open each vendor's profile for full detail.
| Pricing | A Ashby |
G Gem |
|---|---|---|
|
Entry price Lowest public entry point |
From $400/mo | Contact sales |
|
Pricing confidence How public the numbers are |
Public, partial | Contact only |
|
Billing Primary billing axis |
Hybrid. The plan price is set by company size band, not by recruiter seats, and SMS, sourcing email lookups and AI Credits carry stated allowances with paid extras beyond them. | flat |
|
Variable cost Workload / overage exposure |
Low variable cost | Medium variable cost |
|
Free tier / trial Try before you buy |
No free tier
|
No free tier
|
|
Buying motion Self-serve vs sales call |
Mixed | Sales call |
|
Pricing verified When this pricing was last checked |
More comparisons with Ashby or Gem
Other matchups in enterprise operations agents
Not the pairing you were after? These compare a different set of enterprise operations agents on the same 14 capabilities.